Falsely Accused of a Crime in New York: What to Do? 2025

Individuals facing criminal charges in New York can potentially be dealing with significant criminal penalties, such as long periods of time in jail or prison, hefty fines, and a criminal record. On top of grappling with the severity of criminal charges, those falsely accused of a crime in New York can suffer significant emotional distress and anxiety about how their future will pan out. Fortunately, there are concrete steps they can take to protect their rights and interests.

5 Steps You Can Take if You’ve Been Falsely Accused of a Crime in New York

1. Maintain Your Calm and Avoid Impulsive Reactions

Many individuals who are falsely accused of crimes have the first instinct to confront their accusers. In criminal cases, this can be highly disadvantageous for the defendant, leading to potential statements that could inadvertently implicate them in the crime or escalated situations that could lead to further charges. Therefore, it is important to stay as calm as possible and avoid any contact with the accuser.

2. Do Not Speak With Law Enforcement Without an Attorney Present

If law enforcement tries to approach you for questioning, it is crucial to exercise your right to remain silent. Even if you believe that you can quickly and easily prove your innocence, do not try to explain your situation without an attorney present. This is because any statements you make could be misconstrued and eventually used against you as evidence. Firmly but politely tell authorities you cannot be subject to questioning without an attorney present.

3. Get in Touch With a Skilled Criminal Defense Lawyer

Hiring a knowledgeable and experienced criminal defense lawyer can make all the difference in your case. They can help you understand the charges you are facing and the evidence against you and work to build up a strong defense strategy that negates false accusations you are facing. If necessary, they can advocate fiercely on their behalf in court, as well as handle all communications with law enforcement and other authorities.

4. Navigate the Criminal Defense Process Privately

After securing a knowledgeable lawyer who you trust, they can assist you with collecting robust evidence to build up your side of the story, such as photographic or video evidence, in addition to emails. As your case develops, it is crucial to avoid discussing it publicly, such as with friends, family, or on social media. This could complicate your case and lead to negative consequences. By trusting in your attorney, you can present a strong case that brings the truth to light.

5. Consider Filing for Damages

If the false accusations made against you were made in a malicious manner, you may be entitled to file a civil lawsuit to pursue compensation for damages. Your attorney can help you understand whether this could be a viable avenue for you to receive compensation.

FAQs

See also:

What is the Crime of Conspiracy?

What Are the Grounds for Suppressing Evidence in a New York or Federal Criminal Case?

Can You Hire a Federal Criminal Attorney Before Charges Are Filed?